Thursday, August 30, 2012
Wesch vs. McLuhan
After comparing these two stories, I felt that these two men were similar in a way. McCluhan's short article talked about how humans are losing their social skills. People are interacting in ways that weren't even an option years ago. Today people are more worried about how other people view them online than how people view them in person. People in today's society would rather sit on a computer and talk to someone over a small glass lens. Why? Wesch made an interesting point when he said "When medias change, human relations change". Meaning, when technology allows us to interact with each other through this glass lens, we choose that option. People are now able to connect with people all over the world without leaving their computers. This is hurting social skills in today's society. There is something to be said about seeing someone in person. This is how social skills are developed. Sure, when your chatting someone online, you are talking, yes. However, it is different in person. When chatting online, there are ways to make you seem there without being there. Yes, you are actually chatting with the person although you can go the whole conversation without practically looking at them. You are able to browse the internet, among other things while in this conversation. Yet, when you're in person, you are not given options to avoid the conversation. The conversation happens and you learn to interact with humans through speaking face to face, not lens to lens. And that is what I think both of these authors were getting at.
A point I really liked from Wesch's article that I think relates to my earlier comparison between the two is that YouTube allows you to experience humanity, without fear or anxiety. For some people, speaking to millions of people would be a hard thing to do. Yet, with YouTube you can do this from wherever you choose, without feeling the anxiety you would feel if you actually spoke to all the people that viewed your video, in person. When you make a video or vlog on YouTube, you are only speaking to a glass lens, that nobody is currently watching. Wesch made another great point when he said "It's like everybody is watching, yet there is nobody there". This is why people chose to interact online. The fear you have of speaking in person to other people, is gone, online. You don't have to see anybody and you can just be yourself. No anxiety, no fears.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Ryan, I agree with you when you say that as media changes human relations change. I believe this is very true because there is always new ways of communication coming out and when they do, we as humans adapt to accept these new forms and they shape us, whether we like it or not. I also agree with your point about YouTube. When speaking to a camera and not people, you can come out of your shell and you're more likely to say what you really feel. This way of communicating is the relatively new considering how long the internet has been around.
ReplyDeleteIt's true that we really have lost our sense of audience. Rarely do we have to get up in front of a crowd and speak. And when we do speak in front of a crowd the proliferation of cameras makes it quite possible that we could be rebroadcast to millions. Is this something we keep in mind now as a society? Do we watch what we say--or what we blog about?
ReplyDelete